Menu

Discover our mouth-watering selection of pies, made with the freshest ingredients and a lot of love.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Sausage, Apple & Sage Pie

Italian sausage with granny smith apples and the just right amount of sage.

All
Savory

Lemon Meringue Pie

(SEASONAL) Lemon pudding with baked meringue in our signature crust.

All
Sweet

French Meat Pie

Ground pork and ground beef with a touch of mashed potato and seasonings.

All
Savory

Custard Pie

Old fashioned custard with eggs, cream and vanilla with a touch of nutmeg.

All
Sweet

Cranapple Pie

Fresh local apples and cranberries seasoned with sugar and snuggled in our signature crust.

All
Fruit

Coconut Custard Pie

Eggs, cream, toasted coconut and vanilla with a touch of nutmeg.

All
Sweet

Coconut Cream Pie

Vanilla pudding mixed with toasted coconut, topped with homemade whipped cream.

All
Cream

Clam Pie

A customer favorite. Sautéed sea clams with onions, cracker crumbs and seasoning

All
Savory

Chicken Pot Pie

Our signature chicken pie with carrots, peas and homemade gravy in our flaky crust.

All
Savory

Cherry Pie

Tart whole cherries tossed in sugar in our signature crust.

All
Fruit

Cape Cod Crunch Pie

Chocolate pudding mixed with butter toffee, topped with homemade whipped cream and toffee bits.

All
Cream

Blueberry Pie

A mix of sweet wild Maine blueberries and cultivated blueberries make this a local favorite.

All
Fruit

Beef & Ale Pie

We braise beef in Cape Cod Beer's Porter and add in carrots, pearl onions and potatoes. It's like beef stew in a pie shell!

All
Savory

Banana Cream Pie

Banana pudding and sliced bananas topped with homemade whipped cream.

All
Cream

Apple Pie

Fresh local apples tossed in cinnamon and sugar and snuggled in our signature crust.

All
Fruit

All Berry Pie

All your berries! A mix of raspberries, blueberries, strawberries, cranberries and blackberries in our signature crust.

All
Fruit

Lobster Pie

(SEASONAL) Lobster with buttered bread crumbs and lobster bisque.

All
Savory

Pecan Pie

Southern pecans folded in a buttery sauce.

All
Sweet

Pumpkin Pie

Seasoned pumpkin mixed with cinnamon and baked to perfection in our signature crust.

All
Fruit

Ham & Cheese Quiche

Diced ham with a blend of cheeses.

All
Quiche

Quiche Lorraine

Bacon, onion and a blend of cheese.

All
Quiche

Spinach & Feta Quiche

Fresh spinach and feta cheese.

All
Quiche

Veggie Quiche

A mix of seasonal veggies and cheese.

All
Quiche

Shepherd's Pie

Seasoned ground beef with onions and corn, topped with creamy mashed potatoes and parmesan cheese.

All
Savory

Southwestern Taco Pie

Our signature pie crust filled with ground beef that's seasoned with the perfect blend of spices and cheese to make Taco Tuesday worthwhile!

All
Savory

Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie

Sliced sweet strawberries with tart rhubarb makes this pie a family favorite.

All
Fruit

Sweet Potato Shepherd's Pie

Seasoned ground beef with onions and corn, topped with creamy mashed sweet potatoes and parmesan cheese.

All

Thanksgiving Pie

Tender turkey with stuffing and cranberries on top. Just like Thanksgiving dinner, but in a pie crust!

Savory
All

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

Homemade chocolate chip big cookie baked in our signature crust.

Sweet
All

Key Lime Pie

Real key lime in our graham cracker crust topped with homemade whipped cream.

Cream
All

Peach Pie

Sweet, tender peaches mixed with a touch of sugar in our signature crust.

Fruit
All

Chocolate Cream Pie

Chocolate pudding, homemade whipped cream and chocolate chips.

Cream
All

Buffalo Chicken Pie

Stuffed with slow-cooked, hand-pulled chicken and buffalo sauce.

Savory
All

BBQ Pulled Pork Pie

Slow-roasted pork simmered in sweet barbecue sauce.

Savory
All

Spinach Feta Pie

(VEGETARIAN) Vegetarian's delight. CentervillePie's version of the traditional Spanikopita.

Savory
All

Signature Chicken Pie

Our signature pie is overstuffed with slow-cooked, hand-pulled chicken and homemade gravy.

Savory
All
View Menu as PDF

How to order

Bakery & in-store:

Some of our pies are available exclusively at our bakery or select stores. These pies are crafted with the same attention to detail and quality but are not available for shipping.

Locations
Centerville Pie Co Local Bakery case

Delivery Nationwide:

Many of our homestyle pies can be shipped directly to your doorstep, so you can enjoy a slice of Centerville Pies no matter where you are in the continental U.S.

Get it Shipped

How to bake

Savory pies:

  • Set oven to 350 degrees
  • Place frozen pie on the bottom rack
  • Small pies bake for 1 hour
  • Large pies bake for 1.5 hours

Fruit pies:

  • Set oven to 400 degrees
  • Bake for 20 minutes on the bottom rack
  • Then reduce heat to 350 degrees and bake for an additional 60 mins

Handmade with Care

*

Baked to Perfection

*

Filled with Comfort

*

Tastes like Home

*

Handmade with Care

*

Baked to Perfection

*

Filled with Comfort

*

Tastes like Home

*

Handmade with Care

*

Customer love

Opening quotation mark

These pies are beyond delicious! What a special thing to give your guests. I give them as gifts, they are that good! I just drove in from Rhode Island and bought about 20 pies to get ready for Thanksgiving. The staff couldn’t be nicer.”

— Sarah M.
Opening quotation mark

Your chicken pie is amazing! Found it at our local grocery store; will definitely purchase again. And now that I see all these other items you offer by browsing your Facebook page, I’ll have to keep an eye out for more of your products!

— Melinda N.
Opening quotation mark

The best chicken pot pie I’ve had in a long time!!! Mom used to make these, but honestly, yours is better - yummy!!!”

— Monique L.
Arrow in circle
Arrow in circle

Stay in touch.

Subscribe for updates – no spam, all pies.

Follow us on social

Instagram iconFacebook icon